320 cities · 12,480+ places · updated weekly
See what's trending →
Add your place
Cafe Menu 4.6 · 1,068 reviews $10 to $20

Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop Menu

New York, United States

Menu last updated: Mar 15, 2026

Explore Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop menu featuring sandwiches, subs, breakfast, and quick bites in Steamburg, NY. Affordable prices from $1–10. Visit via Locallya..

View Restaurant Get Directions Call
View Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop Photo Menu 1 View Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop Photo Menu 2 Zoom Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop Photo Menu 3 View all photos

Restaurant

Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop

Cuisine

Cafe

Location

New York

Price

$10 to $20

Rating

4.6 / 5

Profile

View restaurant

Most ordered

The items regulars come back for at {brand_name}.

Whole Wheat Bread

Whole Wheat Bread
Pizza Sub

Pizza Sub
Sub of the Day Pizza

Sub of the Day Pizza
Turkey on Wheat

Turkey on Wheat
Turkey Salad

Turkey Salad
Full menu

Full Menu

Browse the complete Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop menu with current prices and options.

Pizza

  • Cheese

    $8.49

  • Pepperoni

    $9.89

  • 3 Meat

    $12.89

  • Signature Blt

    $15.89

  • Chicken Tender

    $14.49

  • Chicken, Bacon, Ranch

    $13.99

Apps & Sides

  • Chicken Fingers

    $7.59

  • Fish Bites

    $4.99

  • Pepperoni Balls

    $4.79

  • Nachos & Cheese

    $3.49

  • Pizza Logs

    $5.79

  • Buffalo Chicken Logs

    $6.99

  • Pretzel Sticks

    $3.99

  • Goliath Pretzel

    $11.99

  • Cheese Nuggets

    $3.49

  • Mac & Cheese Bites

    $3.49

Monster Subs

  • Philly Cheesesteak

    $11.99

  • Italian Sausage Hoagie

    $9.99

  • Bologna

    $5.79

  • Blt

    $6.29

  • Cappicola

    $6.29

  • Cheese

    $4.99

  • Ham

    $8.49

  • Salami

    $5.99

  • Italian

    $6.49

  • Pepperoni

    $5.99

  • Roast Beef

    $7.99

  • Turkey

    $6.99

  • Veggie

    $4.49

  • 2 Meat

    $7.49

  • 3 Meat

    $7.99

Salads

  • Chef Salad

    $8.19

  • Chicken Salad

    $8.19

  • Steak Salad

    $8.19

Hot Subs

  • Cheeseburger

    $6.49

  • Chicken Finger

    $6.49

  • Chicken Parm

    $6.49

  • Meatball

    $6.49

  • Pizza

    $5.99

  • Fish

    $6.49

Sandwiches

  • Steakburger

    $5.99

  • Philly Cheesesteak

  • Italian Sausage Hoagie

    $5.49

  • Grilled Chicken

    $5.99

  • Hamburger

    $3.99

  • Hot Dog

    $1.99

  • Deli Sandwich

Wraps

  • Meat, Cheese & Toppings

    $5.49

Breakfast

  • Combo

    $4.49

  • Breakfast Sandwich

    $3.99

  • Breakfast Logs

    $3.99

  • Breakfast Wrap

    $4.49

  • Hash Brown

    $1.29

  • French Toast Sticks

    $3.99

  • Breakfast Pizza

    $2.99

Others

  • Deli Meat & Cheese

Dietary & food tags

What this menu is great for

Popular for breakfast, lunch, and solo dining, the menu highlights comfort food, coffee, and local specialties served in a casual and quiet atmosphere.

Coffee Comfort food Quick bite Breakfast Brunch Lunch Dinner Solo dining Wheelchair accessible Kids' menu

Dietary and allergen details may vary; please inquire directly for specific needs.

Plan a visit

Visiting Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop

Open daily with easy parking and wheelchair accessible facilities. No reservations accepted. Typical visit duration is about 10 minutes. Payment by cards and mobile payments accepted.

1974 West Perimeter Road, Steamburg, NY 14783, United States
Get Directions Call View Restaurant Profile

Today at Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop

  • Closed
  • +1 716-354-2298
  • Onsite services · Takeout · Dine-in · No Delivery
  • Credit cards · Debit cards · NFC mobile payments
About the menu

About the Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop Menu

Coffee & Comfort Food Price Range: $1–10 Rated 4.6 from 1,068 reviews Open for Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch & Dinner Casual, Quiet Atmosphere Onsite, Takeout & Dine-in Services

The menu features a diverse selection ranging from breakfast wraps and logs to hearty monster subs and classic sandwiches like hamburgers and Philly cheesesteaks. Hands-on comfort foods such as chicken fingers and buffalo chicken logs serve as popular apps and sides alongside fresh salads and specialty pizzas.

Focus is placed on quick bites and satisfying meals that cater well to solo diners and those looking for a casual spot to enjoy a local specialty or grab great coffee. Menu sections include Pizza, Monster Subs, Sandwiches, Apps & Sides, Breakfast, Hot Subs, and Salads, offering options throughout the day.

Service is provided without table service, reflecting the cafe’s straightforward and efficient approach. Many visitors appreciate the welcoming staff and reasonable prices, making it a favored stop for both tourists and locals seeking comfort food paired with tobacco shop offerings.

Menu items and availability may change without notice; prices are subject to updates. Delivery is currently not offered.

The menu features a variety of items including appetizers and sides like Buffalo Chicken Logs and Cheese Nuggets, breakfast options such as Breakfast Pizza, sandwiches including Philly Cheesesteak and Italian Sausage Hoagie, as well as salads and pizzas.

Takeout service is available, allowing guests to enjoy menu items offsite. However, delivery is not offered at this location.

The cafe offers quick bite options and breakfast items including their popular Breakfast Pizza, making it convenient for a short visit or a morning meal.

Menu highlights include local specialties alongside comfort food favorites. The variety ranges from wraps to monster subs and deli selections.

A Kids' menu is available to accommodate younger guests with dishes suited for children.

Menu prices generally range from $1 to $10, offering affordable options across multiple food categories.

More menus to browse

Similar restaurants with menus

Other Cafe in New York with menus on Locallya.

Super Tortas Calientes Madero
Mexican Torta Restaurant

Super Tortas Calientes Madero Menu

343, Eje Metropolitano 30, Treviño, 64000 Monterrey, N.L., Mexico

4.4 View Menu
Restaurant La Peña
Restaurant

Restaurant La Peña Menu

80 Bd du Front de Mer, 11210 Port-la-Nouvelle, France

4.4 View Menu
Los Braseros Mexican Restaurant
Mexican Restaurant

Los Braseros Mexican Restaurant Menu

9207 N Lamar Blvd, Austin, TX 78753, United States

4.1 View Menu
Fogon Del Pastor, Tacos Parrilla Y Mas
Taco Restaurant

Fogon Del Pastor, Tacos Parrilla Y Mas Menu

Av Colinas del Cimatario 226 Col, Colinas del Cimatario, 76090 Santiago de Querétaro, Qro., Mexico

4.3 View Menu
Abaseen
Afghan Restaurant

Abaseen Menu

858 Leeds Rd, Bradford BD3 8EZ, United Kingdom

4.4 View Menu
For business owners

Own or manage this restaurant?

Help customers find the latest menu by updating dishes, prices, photos, and availability. Keep your Turtle Pit Cafe & Smoke Shop listing accurate on Locallya.

  • Free to claim & verify
  • Edit menu items anytime
  • Update prices & photos
  • Respond to customer reviews
Claim this listing Suggest a menu update